Skip to main content
myfinancemyntra

Loan Comparison Calculator: Compare Up to 3 Offers

Put three loan offers side by side and see which truly costs the least after interest and fees.

Updated July 23, 2026More debt tools

Your numbers

The loan
Loan A
Loan B
Loan C

Cheapest total cost

$3,199

Loan C saves $464.

Loan A cost
$3,662
Loan B cost
$4,446
Loan C cost
$3,199
Cheapest payment
$644
Lowest payment
$401

Loan B.

Loan comparison

LoanAPRTermPaymentInterestTotal cost
Loan A8.50%48 mo$493$3,662$3,662
Loan B7.50%60 mo$401$4,046$4,446
Loan C ★9.90%36 mo$644$3,199$3,199

Your personalized analysis

Summary

Loan C is the cheapest — $3,199 total cost

Across interest and fees, Loan C costs $3,199 to borrow $20,000, $464 less than the next-best offer. Its payment is $644 a month over 36 months. The cheapest loan isn't always the one with the lowest payment or even the lowest rate — the term and fees matter too.

Watch out

The lowest payment (Loan B) isn't the cheapest loan

Loan B has the smallest monthly payment at $401, but it costs $1,247 more overall than Loan C — usually because a longer term spreads smaller payments over more months of interest. A low payment can disguise a more expensive loan.

Recommendation

Compare total cost, then check the payment fits

The right way to choose: find the lowest total cost, then confirm its monthly payment is affordable. If the cheapest loan's payment is too high, the next option may be a reasonable trade — but you'll know exactly what the lower payment costs you in extra interest and fees.

Next step

Model your chosen loan in detail

Once you've picked an offer, see its full amortization and the real cost after any origination fee.

Personal loan calculator

Example calculations

Worked scenarios with the full analysis, so you can see how the numbers move before entering your own.

Three offers on a $20,000 loan

A borrower weighing three lenders with different rates, terms and fees on the same amount.

Cheapest total cost

$3,199

Loan A cost
$3,662
Loan B cost
$4,446
Loan C cost
$3,199
Cheapest payment
$644
Lowest payment
$401
Summary

Loan C is the cheapest — $3,199 total cost

Across interest and fees, Loan C costs $3,199 to borrow $20,000, $464 less than the next-best offer. Its payment is $644 a month over 36 months. The cheapest loan isn't always the one with the lowest payment or even the lowest rate — the term and fees matter too.

Watch out

The lowest payment (Loan B) isn't the cheapest loan

Loan B has the smallest monthly payment at $401, but it costs $1,247 more overall than Loan C — usually because a longer term spreads smaller payments over more months of interest. A low payment can disguise a more expensive loan.

Recommendation

Compare total cost, then check the payment fits

The right way to choose: find the lowest total cost, then confirm its monthly payment is affordable. If the cheapest loan's payment is too high, the next option may be a reasonable trade — but you'll know exactly what the lower payment costs you in extra interest and fees.

Same rate, different terms

Comparing how the term alone changes total cost when the rate is identical.

Cheapest total cost

$2,562

Loan A cost
$2,562
Loan B cost
$3,436
Loan C cost
$4,332
Cheapest payment
$627
Lowest payment
$406
Summary

Loan A is the cheapest — $2,562 total cost

Across interest and fees, Loan A costs $2,562 to borrow $20,000, $874 less than the next-best offer. Its payment is $627 a month over 36 months. The cheapest loan isn't always the one with the lowest payment or even the lowest rate — the term and fees matter too.

Watch out

The lowest payment (Loan C) isn't the cheapest loan

Loan C has the smallest monthly payment at $406, but it costs $1,769 more overall than Loan A — usually because a longer term spreads smaller payments over more months of interest. A low payment can disguise a more expensive loan.

Recommendation

Compare total cost, then check the payment fits

The right way to choose: find the lowest total cost, then confirm its monthly payment is affordable. If the cheapest loan's payment is too high, the next option may be a reasonable trade — but you'll know exactly what the lower payment costs you in extra interest and fees.

Low rate with a big fee

A tempting low rate undermined by a large origination fee versus a no-fee option.

Cheapest total cost

$2,577

Loan A cost
$2,975
Loan B cost
$2,577
Loan C cost
$2,609
Cheapest payment
$366
Lowest payment
$356
Summary

Loan B is the cheapest — $2,577 total cost

Across interest and fees, Loan B costs $2,577 to borrow $15,000, $32 less than the next-best offer. Its payment is $366 a month over 48 months. The cheapest loan isn't always the one with the lowest payment or even the lowest rate — the term and fees matter too.

Watch out

The lowest payment (Loan A) isn't the cheapest loan

Loan A has the smallest monthly payment at $356, but it costs $397 more overall than Loan B — usually because a longer term spreads smaller payments over more months of interest. A low payment can disguise a more expensive loan.

Recommendation

Compare total cost, then check the payment fits

The right way to choose: find the lowest total cost, then confirm its monthly payment is affordable. If the cheapest loan's payment is too high, the next option may be a reasonable trade — but you'll know exactly what the lower payment costs you in extra interest and fees.

Mortgage-size comparison

Using the tool for larger loans, where small rate differences translate to big dollar amounts.

Cheapest total cost

$370,975

Loan A cost
$385,633
Loan B cost
$370,975
Loan C cost
$400,486
Cheapest payment
$1,847
Lowest payment
$1,847
Summary

Loan B is the cheapest — $370,975 total cost

Across interest and fees, Loan B costs $370,975 to borrow $300,000, $14,659 less than the next-best offer. Its payment is $1,847 a month over 360 months. The cheapest loan isn't always the one with the lowest payment or even the lowest rate — the term and fees matter too.

Recommendation

Compare total cost, then check the payment fits

The right way to choose: find the lowest total cost, then confirm its monthly payment is affordable. If the cheapest loan's payment is too high, the next option may be a reasonable trade — but you'll know exactly what the lower payment costs you in extra interest and fees.

Next step

Model your chosen loan in detail

Once you've picked an offer, see its full amortization and the real cost after any origination fee.

Personal loan calculator

The basics

Why the lowest payment isn't the cheapest loan

When comparing loans, it's tempting to pick the one with the smallest monthly payment. But a low payment usually comes from a longer term, which means you pay interest for more months — often making the loan more expensive overall. The number that actually matters is total cost: all the interest plus any fees.

Two loans can have very different payments but similar total costs, or the same payment and wildly different costs. This tool lines up to three offers on the same amount and shows the payment, total interest and total cost of each, so you can see past the monthly figure to what the loan really costs.

  • Total cost = total interest + all fees
  • A longer term lowers the payment but raises total interest
  • The lowest rate can lose to a lower-fee offer
  • Compare total cost first, then check affordability

Going deeper

Rate, term and fees together

Three variables drive a loan's cost, and they interact. A lower rate is good, but a big origination fee can wipe out the savings — which is why a slightly higher-rate, no-fee loan sometimes wins. The term is the most underrated: extending it lowers the payment but can add years of interest, so the cheapest loan is often the one with the shortest affordable term.

The disciplined approach is to rank by total cost, then sanity-check the monthly payment against your budget. If the cheapest option's payment is uncomfortable, stepping to the next-cheapest is a deliberate trade you can now measure — you'll see exactly how much the lower payment costs in extra interest. That beats picking on payment alone and overpaying without realizing it.

Common mistakes

  1. 1

    Choosing by monthly payment

    The lowest payment is often the most expensive loan. Compare total cost, which includes all interest and fees.

  2. 2

    Ignoring fees

    A low rate with a big origination fee can lose to a no-fee loan. Include fees in the comparison.

  3. 3

    Overlooking the term's impact

    A longer term lowers the payment but can nearly double the interest. The term is often the biggest cost driver.

  4. 4

    Not checking for prepayment penalties

    Some loans charge to pay off early. Confirm you can prepay before committing, especially if you may refinance.

  5. 5

    Comparing different amounts

    Compare offers on the same loan amount, or the totals aren't apples-to-apples.

Common questions

How do I compare loan offers?

Apply the same loan amount to each offer, then compare total cost — all interest plus fees — not just the monthly payment. This tool does that for up to three loans, showing payment, total interest and total cost side by side. The cheapest total cost is the best deal, provided its payment fits your budget.

Why isn't the loan with the lowest payment the cheapest?

Because a low payment usually comes from a longer term, which spreads smaller payments over more months of interest. A loan with a higher payment but shorter term often costs far less overall. Always compare total cost, since the monthly payment can disguise a more expensive loan.

Does a lower interest rate always mean a cheaper loan?

Not necessarily. A low rate paired with a large origination fee can cost more than a slightly higher-rate loan with no fee. Rate, term and fees all affect the total, which is why comparing the full cost — as this calculator does — beats comparing any single number.

How much does the loan term affect total cost?

Significantly. Extending a loan's term lowers the monthly payment but adds interest for the extra months. On the same rate and amount, going from a 3-year to a 6-year term can nearly double the total interest. The cheapest loan is usually the one with the shortest term you can comfortably afford.

What should I prioritize when choosing a loan?

Rank offers by total cost first, then confirm the monthly payment fits your budget. If the cheapest loan's payment is too high, moving to the next option is a measured trade-off — you'll see exactly how much extra it costs. Also confirm there's no prepayment penalty, so you can pay it off early if you're able.

Glossary

Total cost
All interest plus fees over the life of the loan — the true basis for comparison.
APR
Annual percentage rate — the yearly cost including fees, though total cost also depends on the term.
Term
The number of months to repay; a longer term lowers the payment but raises total interest.
Origination fee
An upfront charge some lenders add, which raises the loan's real cost.
Prepayment penalty
A fee some loans charge for paying off early; worth avoiding where possible.
Total repayment
Everything you pay back — principal, interest and fees combined.

Related tools

The next calculations that usually follow this one.

  • Personal Loan Calculator

    See your monthly payment, total interest and the real cost of a personal loan after origination fees.

  • Auto Loan Calculator

    See your real monthly payment after tax, trade-in and fees — plus the total interest a longer term quietly adds.

  • Mortgage Calculator

    See principal, interest, taxes, insurance and PMI — then what the loan really costs over 30 years.

  • Debt Payoff Calculator

    Enter your balances, get a payoff date — and see exactly what the easier order costs you.

  • Debt-to-Income Calculator

    The single number lenders check first — and the one that decides your mortgage approval.

Read next

Guides that explain the decisions behind these numbers.

  • beginner10 min read

    Debt Payoff Strategies That Work

    Compare debt payoff methods, understand when consolidation helps, and see why payment size matters far more than payoff order.

    Updated January 15, 2026

  • beginner8 min read

    Budgeting Basics

    How to build a budget on take-home pay using the 50/30/20 framework, account for irregular annual costs, and fix the categories that actually matter.

    Updated January 15, 2026

  • intermediate8 min read

    Understanding Mortgage Rates

    How mortgage rates are determined, what moves them, and the six factors that decide whether you get the advertised rate or half a point above it.

    Updated January 15, 2026

More in debt

One useful money idea a week

New tools, guides and the occasional thing that will genuinely save you money. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.

Developer note: this form has no backend. Connect an email provider and add a privacy policy before collecting real addresses.