See what's left after income tax and the 10% penalty — and what that money would have become if you left it alone.
You'd keep
$17,000
32% lost to tax and penalty.
After 3% inflation.
Federal income tax on the withdrawal is roughly $5,500, plus a $2,500 early-withdrawal penalty because you're under 59½. That's $8,000 gone — 32% of the withdrawal — leaving $17,000. State income tax, where it applies, would reduce that further.
Withdrawing before 59½ triggers an additional 10% federal penalty on the amount, here $2,500. Some exceptions exist — separation from service at 55+, certain medical expenses, disability, or substantially equal periodic payments — but they're narrow. Check whether one applies before assuming the penalty is unavoidable.
The real cost isn't just the tax — it's the compounding you give up. Left invested at 7% for the 25 years until 65, $25,000 would become about $135,686 (roughly $64,804 in today's money). Cashing out trades that for $17,000 today.
Before cashing out, look at a 401(k) loan (repaid to yourself, no tax or penalty if repaid on schedule), a hardship withdrawal if you qualify, rolling the balance to an IRA if you've left the job, or lower-cost borrowing. Cashing out a retirement account is usually the most expensive option available, and it's permanent — you can't put the money back.
If you can avoid the withdrawal, model what the balance becomes over your remaining working years.
401(k) calculatorWorked scenarios with the full analysis, so you can see how the numbers move before entering your own.
A mid-career withdrawal facing both income tax and the 10% early penalty.
You'd keep
$17,000
Federal income tax on the withdrawal is roughly $5,500, plus a $2,500 early-withdrawal penalty because you're under 59½. That's $8,000 gone — 32% of the withdrawal — leaving $17,000. State income tax, where it applies, would reduce that further.
Withdrawing before 59½ triggers an additional 10% federal penalty on the amount, here $2,500. Some exceptions exist — separation from service at 55+, certain medical expenses, disability, or substantially equal periodic payments — but they're narrow. Check whether one applies before assuming the penalty is unavoidable.
The real cost isn't just the tax — it's the compounding you give up. Left invested at 7% for the 25 years until 65, $25,000 would become about $135,686 (roughly $64,804 in today's money). Cashing out trades that for $17,000 today.
A smaller withdrawal far from retirement, where the lost compounding is largest.
You'd keep
$6,800
Federal income tax on the withdrawal is roughly $2,200, plus a $1,000 early-withdrawal penalty because you're under 59½. That's $3,200 gone — 32% of the withdrawal — leaving $6,800. State income tax, where it applies, would reduce that further.
Withdrawing before 59½ triggers an additional 10% federal penalty on the amount, here $1,000. Some exceptions exist — separation from service at 55+, certain medical expenses, disability, or substantially equal periodic payments — but they're narrow. Check whether one applies before assuming the penalty is unavoidable.
The real cost isn't just the tax — it's the compounding you give up. Left invested at 7% for the 35 years until 65, $10,000 would become about $106,766 (roughly $37,943 in today's money). Cashing out trades that for $6,800 today.
A withdrawal after 59½, where only income tax applies.
You'd keep
$42,695
Federal income tax on the withdrawal is roughly $7,305. That's $7,305 gone — 15% of the withdrawal — leaving $42,695. State income tax, where it applies, would reduce that further.
The real cost isn't just the tax — it's the compounding you give up. Left invested at 6% for the 3 years until 65, $50,000 would become about $59,551 (roughly $54,497 in today's money). Cashing out trades that for $42,695 today.
Before cashing out, look at a 401(k) loan (repaid to yourself, no tax or penalty if repaid on schedule), a hardship withdrawal if you qualify, rolling the balance to an IRA if you've left the job, or lower-cost borrowing. Cashing out a retirement account is usually the most expensive option available, and it's permanent — you can't put the money back.
A joint filer withdrawal, where wider brackets soften the income tax.
You'd keep
$20,400
Federal income tax on the withdrawal is roughly $6,600, plus a $3,000 early-withdrawal penalty because you're under 59½. That's $9,600 gone — 32% of the withdrawal — leaving $20,400. State income tax, where it applies, would reduce that further.
Withdrawing before 59½ triggers an additional 10% federal penalty on the amount, here $3,000. Some exceptions exist — separation from service at 55+, certain medical expenses, disability, or substantially equal periodic payments — but they're narrow. Check whether one applies before assuming the penalty is unavoidable.
The real cost isn't just the tax — it's the compounding you give up. Left invested at 7% for the 20 years until 65, $30,000 would become about $116,091 (roughly $64,277 in today's money). Cashing out trades that for $20,400 today.
Withdrawing from a 401(k) before age 59½ has two immediate costs. The amount is added to your taxable income for the year, taxed at your marginal rate, and a 10% federal early-withdrawal penalty applies on top. Between the two, a third or more of the withdrawal commonly disappears — and state income tax, where applicable, takes more.
The larger cost is invisible: the decades of compounding you forfeit. $25,000 withdrawn at 40 isn't just $25,000 — at a 7% return it's roughly $135,000 of retirement money at 65. That's the real trade being made, and it's why cashing out is usually the most expensive way to solve a short-term cash need.
Some withdrawals escape the 10% penalty: separation from service in or after the year you turn 55 (the 'rule of 55'), total and permanent disability, certain unreimbursed medical expenses, substantially equal periodic payments under Rule 72(t), and a few others. Income tax still applies in every case — the exceptions waive only the penalty. If you're facing a withdrawal, check carefully whether one fits.
Better options usually exist. A 401(k) loan lets you borrow from yourself with no tax or penalty if repaid on schedule, though it becomes a taxable distribution if you leave the job and can't repay. If you've already left an employer, rolling the balance to an IRA preserves it entirely. And ordinary borrowing — even at a moderate rate — is often cheaper than losing a third of the money plus decades of growth.
Rolling to an IRA or the new plan preserves the balance entirely. Cashing out is the most expensive option.
Income tax plus 10% penalty plus state tax can take a third or more. Budget from the net, not the gross.
The forfeited growth usually dwarfs the tax. A withdrawal at 40 can cost five times its value by 65.
The rule of 55, disability and medical exceptions can waive the penalty. Many people never check.
Borrowing from yourself avoids tax and penalty if repaid on schedule — usually far cheaper than a withdrawal.
The withdrawal is added to your taxable income and taxed at your marginal rate, plus a 10% federal penalty if you're under 59½. For someone earning $75,000 withdrawing $25,000, that's roughly $5,500 in federal tax plus $2,500 penalty — about a third of the withdrawal, before any state tax.
It's an additional federal tax on distributions from retirement accounts taken before age 59½, on top of ordinary income tax. Certain exceptions waive it — the rule of 55, disability, some medical expenses, and substantially equal periodic payments — but income tax still applies even when the penalty doesn't.
In limited situations: if you separate from service in or after the year you turn 55, become totally disabled, have certain large unreimbursed medical expenses, or take substantially equal periodic payments under Rule 72(t). After 59½ no penalty applies at all. In every case, income tax on the withdrawal still applies.
Usually yes. A 401(k) loan isn't taxed or penalized as long as you repay it on schedule, and you pay the interest back to your own account. The risk is that leaving your job can make the outstanding balance due quickly, and any unpaid amount becomes a taxable distribution with penalty. Still, it's typically far cheaper than cashing out.
Far more than the tax and penalty. $25,000 withdrawn at age 40 costs roughly $8,000 in immediate tax and penalty — but at a 7% return that money would have grown to about $135,000 by age 65. The lost compounding is usually several times the immediate cost, which is why cashing out is rarely worth it.
The next calculations that usually follow this one.
See what your contributions and your employer's match grow into — and whether you're leaving free money on the table.
Find your target, see the gap, and check whether you are leaving employer money behind.
Bracket-by-bracket breakdown, your effective rate, and what the next dollar costs.
Compare converting now and paying tax today against leaving the money to grow and be taxed in retirement.
See how long a portfolio survives at your withdrawal rate, with inflation raising the amount you need each year.
Guides that explain the decisions behind these numbers.
How to calculate what you need to retire, choose between Roth and traditional accounts, and understand withdrawal rates and Social Security timing.
Updated January 15, 2026
How US federal tax brackets work, the difference between marginal and effective rates, and the deductions and accounts that actually reduce your bill.
Updated January 15, 2026
New tools, guides and the occasional thing that will genuinely save you money. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.
Developer note: this form has no backend. Connect an email provider and add a privacy policy before collecting real addresses.